T is for Titanic (1953). The film won Best
Original Screenplay at the Academy Awards, and after having watched it, I can
appreciate why. It is a very well written story. The film is not rated.
I was curious what I’d see when watching this original film
that was made 44 years prior to the famous Titanic
from James Cameron that captured young girls hearts all across the world. This
black and white film from 1953 begins with an image of an iceberg calving off of
a glacier and crashing into the Atlantic Ocean, thus beginning its drift into
the path of the maiden and only voyage of the ship the Titanic.
In April of 1912, both wealthy class and working class,
about 2200 passengers, are aboard for a journey to America from Southampton,
England. Some of the same storyline is later reflected in the storytelling of
James Cameron, and other parts in this film are less well known.
In the unfolding of this tragedy, the writers use a
fictional family to focus our sympathies on. Richard Ward Sturges (Clifton Webb)
rushes to board the ship at the last minute in pursuit of his estranged wife
Julia (Barbara Stanwyck) who is leaving Europe for Michigan, Mackinac Island to
be exact, with their two children, Annette (Audrey Dalton) and Norman (Harper
Carter). Richard is trying to mend their broken relationship when the disaster
strikes.
Also onboard is a group of students from Purdue University,
including Gifford Rogers (Robert Wagner), who is enchanted by Annette and
attempts to win her over during the sailing. Maude Young (Thelma Ritter) is a
card shark with a smart mouth, and I wondered if she was the counterpart to
Molly Brown played by Kathy Bates in the later version.
We also see the warnings of impending disaster that were
directed to Captain E. J. Smith (Brian Aherne), and the unfortunate lack of
necessary equipment that may have diverted the accident. The film is said to be
true to the navigational data gathered during investigations into the tragic
sinking of the Titanic.
With none of the over the top visual effects that the Titanic of 1997 employed, I actually liked
this version better. The actors are all first rate, especially Barbara Stanwyck
and the young, handsome Robert Wagner. A few fictionalized stories of the other
passengers are thrown in, and it is a well-balanced film that was also
nominated for an Academy Award for Best Art Direction-Set Decoration (but did
not receive the award).
It is first and foremost a drama, and a reminder that human
error and laxity in safety measures is what really caused the fatal injury to
the vessel, and the deaths of so many travelers (approximately 1500 people).
Thankfully for those sailing on large ocean going vessels today, the safety
standards are high and must be adhered to. It is a sad film, but a fitting
tribute to the innocent souls who lost their lives that cold pre-dawn morning
in April of 1912.
Hi Sue - I remember at our school church there was a plaque remembering a good few local residents who went down with the Titanic - so it's always resonated.
ReplyDeleteI've never see the first film ... but this one sounds really enchanting for all its sad tale - and yes now I'd love to see it. Though even with all the navigational aids we have - disasters still occur ... often by human error or inattention ...
Thanks - enjoyed this - cheers Hilary
I think you would really find this early film touching and memorable.
DeleteI was surprised watching this after seeing the new version about how much of the fictional stories were copied over to the new film. Like you, I prefered the original.
ReplyDeletehttps://iainkellywriting.com/2018/04/23/t-is-for-talinn-estonia/
Thank you! More people should watch it as it has something the James Cameron film does not.
DeleteThis is far superior to the love boat sinking of 1997 which mainly has great special effects and excellent acting but the writing, and directing sucked. I enjoyed this version very much and found it well acted especially by Clifton Webb. Apparently Barbara Stanwyck and Robert Wagner had an affair on set. If you want an excellent film that recounts the very true stories that occurred on this ship, watch A Night To Remember.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the tip! I will look up A Night to Remember.
Delete